Ghosts In Depth Study

Ghosts Across Faiths: A Comparative Study of Religious Perspectives

1. Introduction: The Universal Specter of Ghosts

The belief in ghosts, the disembodied spirits of the deceased, is a phenomenon that transcends geographical boundaries and historical epochs, manifesting in diverse forms across human cultures. This enduring fascination with the spectral realm suggests a fundamental human curiosity about mortality and the potential for existence beyond physical death. From ancient folklore to contemporary narratives, the concept of ghosts permeates societal consciousness, prompting questions about their nature, origins, and interactions with the living. This report aims to explore the multifaceted concept of ghosts within several major world religions: Hinduism, Islam, Christianity, Buddhism, Sikhism, and Judaism. By examining the theological, scriptural, and cultural perspectives of each faith, this analysis seeks to illuminate both the common threads and the unique interpretations that shape these beliefs. It is important to acknowledge from the outset that the very definition of a "ghost" varies significantly across these religious frameworks, influenced by distinct theological principles and cultural contexts. Therefore, a comparative approach necessitates a careful consideration of the specific terminology and underlying beliefs within each tradition.

2. Hinduism: Restless Spirits and the Cycle of Rebirth

Hinduism presents a rich and intricate understanding of spirits, employing a diverse vocabulary to categorize them based on their origins and characteristics. The term bhut generally refers to a restless ghost, often believed to be malignant, particularly if the individual experienced a violent death or was denied proper funeral rites. These bhuts are often feared by women, children, and the newly married. Another significant term is preta, which denotes a restless spirit, often due to unresolved karma or the improper performance of death rituals. The pishacha represents a more ghoulish type of spirit, while the churel is specifically the ghost of a woman who died during pregnancy or childbirth. These terms highlight a nuanced understanding within Hinduism regarding the different states and forms that spirits can take.

Various Hindu scriptures offer explanations for the existence and nature of these spirits. The Garuda Purana, a sacred text, describes how souls who do not receive proper funeral rites can become trapped as pretas, unable to progress in their spiritual journey. The Bhagavad Gita acknowledges the existence of spirits as beings to whom worship is offered, stating that those who worship ghosts are born among such beings. The Atharva Veda contains rituals like atma-shanti, a modified shraadh (death anniversary), performed by Hindu exorcists to provide peace to or ensure the rebirth of a bhuta. The Brihat Samhita, an ancient astrology text, mentions planetary positions influencing paranormal experiences. These scriptural references indicate that the concept of ghosts is integrated into the broader Hindu theological framework.

The reasons for an individual becoming a ghost in Hindu belief are often linked to specific circumstances surrounding their death or the subsequent rituals. Unfinished karma, a violent or premature death, or the denial of proper funeral rites are frequently cited as factors that can cause a soul to become a restless spirit. This suggests a belief that the manner of death and the observances performed by the living have a significant impact on the soul's transition to the afterlife. The state of being a ghost is generally viewed as a temporary and undesirable condition stemming from these specific circumstances.

Hinduism recognizes different types of ghosts with varying characteristics. While some bhuts are believed to be malignant, others, particularly spirits of deified heroes or benevolent beings, are considered protective. Bhootas are often described as having the ability to shape-shift into various animal forms, although they are most commonly seen in human shape, often with their feet facing backwards. They are believed to inhabit specific locations such as trees, deserts, abandoned houses, and crossroads, but they avoid resting on the ground, which is considered sacred. Certain substances like water and objects made of iron or steel are said to be feared by bhootas, and invoking the names of holy figures or deities is believed to repel them. Specific types of female ghosts, such as the churel (ghost of a woman who died during pregnancy or childbirth) and the mohini (a South Indian ghost who lures young men), have their own unique characteristics and behaviors. This detailed classification illustrates a rich and culturally specific understanding of the spirit world within Hinduism.

Hinduism provides various cultural practices and rituals aimed at liberating restless spirits and offering protection from them. Rudimentary shrines are sometimes established for bhuts, and believers fearing them may invoke Shiva, who is considered their lord. Rituals like Pind Daan, performed at sacred locations like Gaya or Haridwar, are believed to liberate pretas by offering them closure through their descendants. As the soul is considered indestructible in Hinduism, exorcists typically perform rituals like Atma-Shanti from the Atharva Veda to ensure the rebirth of the bhuta or to help it complete unfinished tasks, thus ceasing the haunting. The scent of burnt turmeric and fibers of the herb bhutkeshi are also said to ward off bhootas. These practices demonstrate a proactive approach within Hinduism to managing and interacting with the spirit world. The detailed nature of these beliefs and the associated rituals underscores a strong cultural emphasis on ancestral veneration and the importance of proper death rites for the well-being of both the deceased and the living. The fear of malignant spirits arising from improper rites likely drives the meticulous performance of these rituals, while the belief in benevolent ancestral spirits reinforces the importance of maintaining positive relationships with the departed through worship and offerings.

3. Islam: Jinn, Souls, and the Realm of Barzakh

Islam offers a distinct perspective on the concept of ghosts, generally rejecting the traditional understanding of them as spirits of the dead returning to Earth. Mainstream Islamic theology posits that after death, the soul enters a realm called Barzakh, a transitional state between this life and the Day of Judgment, where it remains until resurrection. This belief in Barzakh implies that the souls of the deceased do not typically roam the earthly plane.

Instead of ghosts, Islam acknowledges the existence of other supernatural entities. The term jinn refers to creatures made of fire, possessing free will and capable of both good and evil actions. The ruh is the soul of a human being, which departs the body at death and enters Barzakh. Every human is also believed to have a qareen, a jinn companion that accompanies them from birth. These terms provide a framework for understanding supernatural phenomena within an Islamic context.

Islamic beliefs about the afterlife and unseen entities are firmly rooted in the Quran and the Hadith (sayings and traditions of Prophet Muhammad). The Quran explicitly mentions the creation of jinn from fire and describes their ability to see humans while remaining unseen. Surah Al-Mu'minun (23:99-100) speaks of a barrier (Barzakh) between the dead and the living, reinforcing the idea that souls do not return to Earth. Hadith traditions also elaborate on the nature and abilities of jinn and the state of the soul after death.

Phenomena often attributed to ghosts, such as paranormal activity and apparitions, are typically explained in Islam through the actions of jinn. Jinn are known for their capacity for mischief, shapeshifting, and interaction with the physical world. Some Muslims believe that rebellious or evil jinn (shaytaan) may attempt to scare or mislead humans. This interpretation provides a theological explanation for such events without contradicting the core Islamic belief that the deceased do not return to this world.

While core Islamic doctrine rejects the concept of ghosts, variations in belief can exist among Muslims, often influenced by local folklore or pre-Islamic traditions. In pre-Islamic Arabia, beliefs about spirits were prevalent, and Islam sought to purify these beliefs by emphasizing the concept of Barzakh and the role of jinn. In Muslim-majority countries with strong local folklore, some individuals may still hold beliefs in ghosts that are not entirely aligned with mainstream Islamic theology. However, educated Islamic scholars generally attribute such beliefs to a lack of proper understanding of Islamic teachings, which prioritize the Quran and Hadith as the primary sources of religious knowledge. This leads to a systematic explanation of the supernatural, integrating phenomena often attributed to ghosts into a broader theological framework centered on the creation and nature of jinn. By providing an alternative explanation for paranormal activity through the concept of jinn, Islam offers a way to understand the unseen world that is consistent with its core doctrines about the afterlife and the nature of God's creation, serving to purify the mind from superstitions not rooted in Islamic texts.

4. Christianity: Angels, Demons, and the Final Judgment

Christianity, based on the teachings of the Bible, generally does not subscribe to the belief in ghosts as disembodied spirits of deceased humans who linger on Earth to haunt the living. Instead, the Bible emphasizes the existence of spirit beings, which are primarily categorized as angels (servants of God) and demons (fallen angels or evil spirits). Apparitions and supernatural occurrences are often attributed to the actions of these spiritual entities.

The terminology surrounding "ghosts" and "spirits" in the Bible can be nuanced. In older translations, particularly the King James Version, "ghost" is often used interchangeably with "spirit," as in the term "Holy Ghost," which refers to the Holy Spirit, the third person of the Trinity. However, in more modern translations, "ghost" is typically used to denote a specter or apparition, often in contexts where the disciples of Jesus mistook him for one after his resurrection. The term "spirit" more broadly refers to any immaterial being, including angels, demons, and the Holy Spirit. The Bible also mentions "familiar spirits," which are understood to be demons that impersonate the deceased to deceive the living.

Christian doctrines regarding the afterlife play a crucial role in the understanding of earthly haunting. The Bible teaches that after death, individuals face judgment, which leads to either eternal life in Heaven for believers or eternal punishment in Hell for unbelievers. Some Christian denominations also believe in Purgatory, an intermediate state for purification before entering Heaven. This understanding of the soul's immediate transition to its final destination after death generally precludes the possibility of souls remaining on Earth as ghosts to haunt the living. Passages like Hebrews 9:27 state that "people are destined to die once, and after that to face judgment," reinforcing the idea of a singular transition rather than a lingering presence on Earth.

The Bible contains explicit warnings against necromancy, the practice of attempting to communicate with the dead. Deuteronomy 18:10-11 and Leviticus 19:31 and 20:27 condemn seeking out mediums and spiritists, describing such practices as detestable to God. These warnings underscore the Christian belief that any perceived contact with the deceased is likely either an illusion or a form of demonic deception. The story of King Saul consulting a medium to summon the spirit of Samuel in 1 Samuel 28 is often cited as an example of a forbidden practice with negative consequences.

While the general Christian stance is that ghosts as wandering human spirits do not exist, some denominations, particularly Catholicism, acknowledge the possibility of God allowing spirits, such as deceased saints, to appear in rare circumstances. These apparitions are typically seen as divine interventions for specific purposes rather than the natural state of departed souls. Some Protestant perspectives also recognize the complexity of reported supernatural experiences, suggesting that not all such events can be simply dismissed as demonic deception and that a discerning approach is necessary. However, the prevailing theological view across most Christian denominations remains that the spirits of the deceased do not typically return to Earth to haunt the living. This perspective is deeply intertwined with Christianity's understanding of the afterlife and the nature of good and evil spiritual forces. The emphasis on a final judgment and the dichotomy of Heaven and Hell leaves little theological space for an intermediate state of wandering spirits. Furthermore, the warning against necromancy highlights a concern about occult practices and potential spiritual deception. The active role attributed to demons in deceiving and harming humans provides a framework for explaining ghostly encounters without contradicting the afterlife doctrine.

5. Buddhism: Realms of Existence and the Hungry Ghosts

Buddhism incorporates the concept of ghosts within its intricate cosmology, framing them as beings within the cycle of Samsara, the continuous process of birth, death, and rebirth. One of the six realms of existence in Buddhist cosmology is the ghost realm, known as Preta-loka. Existence in this realm is often attributed to past actions and unresolved attachments.

Buddhist terminology distinguishes between various types of ghosts. The term preta (Sanskrit) or peta (Pali) generally translates to "Hungry Ghost," referring to beings driven by intense emotional needs and insatiable desires. These beings are often depicted with large, empty stomachs and thin necks, symbolizing their perpetual hunger and inability to find satisfaction. In some classifications, such as in Tibetan Buddhism, the being in the intermediate state between death and rebirth, known as Bardo, is referred to as a gandharva, distinct from pretas. Buddhist texts also describe different categories of pretas based on their past karma and the nature of their suffering, such as ghosts of no wealth, little wealth, and much wealth, each experiencing unique torments.

The existence of ghosts, particularly pretas, in Buddhism is often explained as a direct consequence of negative karma accumulated through past actions. Deeds motivated by greed, stinginess, anger, and ignorance are believed to lead to rebirth in the ghost realm. Strong attachments to material possessions, loved ones, or even to life itself can also result in becoming a lingering spirit or a preta after death. This aligns with the core Buddhist principle that one's actions (karma) have consequences that extend across lifetimes.

The ghost realm in Buddhism is characterized by intense suffering, primarily due to the unsatisfied desires of the pretas. Despite their immense hunger and thirst, they often find it impossible to consume anything, or what they do consume only exacerbates their suffering. However, Buddhism offers paths to alleviate this suffering and potentially lead to a better rebirth. Practices such as the transfer of merit (dedicating the positive results of one's actions) to the deceased and making offerings, especially during specific times like the Ghost Month in East Asia, are believed to help these beings. The Buddha himself is said to have indicated that the ghost realm is the only one out of many that can receive food offerings from humans.

Many Buddhist cultures have developed specific traditions and festivals dedicated to honoring the deceased and providing for the needs of ghosts. The Hungry Ghost Festival, observed in East Asian countries like China and Vietnam, is a significant event where families prepare food, burn paper money and other offerings for the spirits, believing that the gates of hell open during this month, allowing ghosts to roam the earth. These cultural practices reflect the integration of Buddhist beliefs about ghosts into the social and religious life of these communities. The Buddhist understanding of ghosts as beings within the cycle of Samsara, suffering due to their past actions, aligns with the core Buddhist principles of karma and rebirth. The emphasis on compassion extends even to these beings, with practices developed to aid their liberation, reflecting a holistic approach to all forms of existence within the Buddhist worldview.

6. Sikhism: The Inner Ghost and the Cycle of Reincarnation

Sikhism presents a unique and largely metaphorical interpretation of "ghosts," using the terms Bhoot Pret to primarily represent inner vices, spiritual ignorance, and attachment to Maya (worldly illusion) rather than literal disembodied spirits. The Sikh holy scripture, the Sri Guru Granth Sahib (SGGS) or Gurbani, serves as the foundation for this understanding.

The Gurbani equates a person with a corrupted mind or consciousness to a Pret or ghost, defining it as a person's inner nature (Viratee), inclinations, and conduct. A mind afflicted with vices such as lust, anger, greed, and ego is considered ugly or Karoop—a ghost (Bhoot Pret) even while living. Conversely, a person with a reformed or heightened consciousness, possessing divine virtues and wisdom, is considered a Devtaa or god-like. The concept of Jamm Doot, traditionally messengers of death, is also reinterpreted as the fear and experience of suffering resulting from attachment to Maya within this life. These metaphorical definitions highlight Sikhism's focus on inner transformation.

Numerous verses in the Gurbani support this metaphorical understanding. The scripture asserts that anyone attached to Maya or lacking wisdom, virtues, and truth is akin to a ghost. It emphasizes that when a person's virtues, wisdom, or humanity dies, they become like ghosts. Forgetting the Divine (Prabh) leads to a state of being like a ghost, and hearts devoid of divine wisdom are likened to cremation grounds inhabited by demons. Duality (Doojaa-Bhaav) itself is considered the worst ghost. These scriptural references underscore the symbolic use of the term "ghost" in Sikh teachings.

Sikhism places a strong emphasis on overcoming ego (Haumai) and achieving spiritual liberation (Mukti) within this lifetime as the path to avoid the cycle of reincarnation in lower forms, which can include being metaphorically described as "ghosts". The religion teaches that the soul undergoes a cycle of reincarnation, with one's actions in this life determining future births. Spiritual progress through meditation on God's name (Naam), imbibing divine wisdom, and cultivating virtues are seen as the means to break free from this cycle and attain union with God.

Sikhism generally discourages belief in traditional superstitions and the fear surrounding ghosts, attributing such beliefs to ignorance and psychological factors. Guru Nanak, the founder of Sikhism, was himself called a ghost by those who could not understand his teachings. Sikh teachings emphasize that fear is a result of evil deeds and that focusing on God and living according to divine commands dispels such fears. The idea of external evil spirits is often viewed as a manifestation of inner ignorance and delusion.

While the dominant theological view in Sikhism is the metaphorical interpretation of ghosts, some interpretations within the tradition acknowledge the possibility of earthbound souls due to strong attachments. It is believed that such souls, unable to cross the electro-magnetic field of the earth after death, may remain earthbound and can sometimes be released through the prayers and spiritual practices of earthly beings, such as the recitation of Akhand Paath. However, this is not the prevailing theological stance within Sikhism. The Sikh metaphorical interpretation of ghosts reflects the religion's focus on inner transformation and ethical conduct as the path to spiritual enlightenment. By redefining "ghost" as a state of mind rather than an external entity, Sikhism encourages individuals to take responsibility for their spiritual well-being in this life rather than fearing supernatural forces. This approach aligns with Sikhism's emphasis on reason and the importance of understanding the divine within oneself, shifting the focus from external fears to internal purification and the cultivation of virtues.

7. Judaism: Souls, Spirits, and the World to Come

Judaism presents a range of perspectives on the possibility of ghosts, with some traditions acknowledging the existence of spirits (Ruach) while others emphasize the soul's journey to Olam Ha'ba (the World to Come) after death. This diversity in thought reflects different interpretations of Jewish texts spanning millennia.

Jewish tradition employs specific terminology for various spiritual entities. A dybbuk is considered a malicious possessing spirit, often the soul of a deceased person who was wronged or sinful in life, that clings to a living person's body. An ibbur refers to a temporary, benevolent spiritual inhabitation where the soul of a righteous deceased person may enter a living person's soul to complete a task. The Talmud mentions sheidim or mazikin, often translated as demons or harmful spirits. The term ruach can refer to spirit or soul. These terms illustrate the nuanced understanding of spiritual entities within Judaism.

Scriptural interpretations of spirits and the afterlife vary within Judaism. The Torah (Deuteronomy 18:11) prohibits "inquiring of the dead," which some interpret as an acknowledgment that communication might be possible but is forbidden. The story of King Saul consulting the Witch of Endor to summon the spirit of Prophet Samuel (1 Samuel 28) is a key scriptural narrative discussed in relation to the possibility of contacting the deceased. The Talmud contains numerous stories about interactions between the living and the dead, as well as accounts of sheidim and mazikin. Kabbalistic traditions offer further interpretations, suggesting that demons and other supernatural entities can arise from misspent life energy. However, the literal interpretation of these texts is often debated, with some scholars viewing them metaphorically.

The Torah's prohibition against communicating with the dead (Deuteronomy 18:11) is a significant point of discussion. Some Jewish thinkers see this as an implication that such communication is indeed possible but strictly forbidden. Others, like Maimonides, take a more rationalist approach, arguing that believing in the ability to invoke dead spirits is not only nonsensical but also contradicts Judaism's monotheistic principles. This difference in interpretation highlights the spectrum of beliefs within Judaism regarding the interaction between the living and the dead.

Jewish folklore is rich with stories of dybbuks, ibburim, and other spirits, often serving to explain misfortunes, illnesses, or explore themes of sin and redemption. The concept of the dybbuk, a soul clinging to a living person, has been particularly prominent in Jewish cultural narratives, exemplified by S. Ansky's famous play "The Dybbuk". Stories of ibburim often depict righteous souls temporarily inhabiting the living to complete good deeds. These folkloric elements reflect cultural anxieties and moral teachings within Jewish tradition. The tension within Judaism between rationalist interpretations that tend to reject literal belief in ghosts and mystical traditions that embrace a more active spirit world illustrates the ongoing dialogue between philosophy and mysticism within Jewish thought. This internal debate shapes the diverse range of beliefs regarding ghosts and other supernatural phenomena. Some thinkers define evil spirits as mental illness, while others take Talmudic and Kabbalistic accounts of demons and spirits literally, reflecting a broader trend in Jewish intellectual history of navigating the relationship between reason and faith.

8. Comparative Analysis and Conclusion: A Cross-Religious Examination of the Spectral

The preceding analysis reveals both recurring themes and significant differences in how major world religions conceptualize ghosts. A comparative overview of the terminology and nature of these entities across the examined faiths is presented in the table below:

Religion	Terminology	Nature and Origin
Hinduism	Bhut, Preta, Pishacha, Churel, Mohini	Restless spirits due to violent death, lack of rites, unresolved karma; can be malignant or benevolent; shape-shifting abilities.
Islam	Jinn, Ruh, Qareen	Rejects ghosts as returning souls; paranormal activity attributed to Jinn (creatures of fire); soul resides in Barzakh after death.
Christianity	Spirit, Ghost, Holy Spirit, Familiar Spirit	Generally rejects ghosts as wandering human spirits; apparitions often attributed to angels or demons; familiar spirits are demonic impersonations.
Buddhism	Preta (Hungry Ghost), Gandharva, Peta	Beings in the realm of Samsara suffering from insatiable desires due to negative karma and attachments; Gandharva in intermediate state.
Sikhism	Bhoot Pret (metaphorical)	Primarily a metaphorical representation of inner vices, spiritual ignorance, and attachment to Maya; some belief in earthbound souls.
Judaism	Dybbuk, Ibbur, Sheidim/Mazikin, Ruach	Diverse views; Dybbuk (malicious possessing spirit), Ibbur (benevolent inhabitation), demons/harmful spirits; debate on literal existence.

Beliefs about ghosts are deeply intertwined with each religion's core theological doctrines regarding death, the soul, and the spiritual realm, as well as the cultural environments in which these religions developed. For instance, religions with a strong emphasis on reincarnation, such as Hinduism and Buddhism, tend to incorporate ghosts as part of the cycle of existence, with their state often determined by karma. In contrast, religions with a linear view of life and a final judgment, like Christianity and Islam, generally do not accommodate the concept of wandering spirits of the deceased. However, even within these traditions, alternative explanations for perceived ghostly phenomena exist, such as the Islamic belief in jinn or the Christian attribution to angels or demons. Judaism presents a more nuanced picture, with a spectrum of beliefs influenced by both philosophical and mystical traditions. Sikhism offers a unique perspective by largely interpreting the concept of ghosts metaphorically, focusing on inner spiritual states rather than external entities.

Belief in ghosts often serves various psychological and societal purposes. These beliefs can provide explanations for unexplained events, reinforce moral codes through the fear of negative consequences in the afterlife, and offer a framework for coping with death and loss. For example, the Hindu emphasis on proper funeral rites and rituals for the liberation of pretas underscores the importance of these practices for the well-being of both the deceased and the living. Similarly, stories of dybbuks in Jewish folklore often explore themes of sin and redemption, serving as moral lessons. The universal nature of ghost beliefs across diverse cultures suggests a fundamental human need to understand and make sense of death and the possibility of what lies beyond.

In conclusion, the concept of ghosts varies significantly across major world religions, shaped by distinct theological frameworks and cultural contexts. While some religions, like Hinduism and Buddhism, incorporate ghosts as specific types of beings within their cosmologies, others, such as Islam and mainstream Christianity, generally reject the notion of wandering spirits of the deceased, offering alternative explanations for perceived paranormal phenomena. Judaism presents a range of views, while Sikhism primarily interprets "ghosts" metaphorically. Despite these differences, the enduring presence of ghost beliefs across faiths underscores the profound human fascination with the mysteries of death and the afterlife, and the various ways in which religious traditions attempt to understand and interpret the spectral realm.

Works cited

1. How the god you worship influences the ghosts you see - The News Minute, https://www.thenewsminute.com/features/how-god-you-worship-influences-ghosts-you-see-71113 2. Bhut | Hindu Mythology, Meaning & Ghost | Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/topic/bhut 3. What Does the Bible Say about Ghosts? - Topical Studies | Bible ..., https://www.biblestudytools.com/bible-study/topical-studies/what-does-the-bible-say-about-ghosts-bst.html 4. Ghosts, Shapeshifters & Demons: What Does the Bible Say About Them? - Harrison House, https://harrisonhouse.com/blog/larry-ollison-ghosts-shapeshifters-and-demons-what-does-the-bible-say-about-them 5. www.britannica.com, https://www.britannica.com/topic/bhut#:~:text=bhut%2C%20in%20Hindu%20mythology%2C%20a,children%2C%20and%20the%20newly%20married. 6. Ghosts & Spirits in Indian Tradition – Vedic Beliefs & Rituals, https://www.ganeshaspeaks.com/predictions/astrology/ghosts-spirits-belief-in-indian-tradition/ 7. Bhoota (ghost) - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhoota_(ghost) 8. Concept of Ghosts in Hinduism - Brahminsnet.com - Forum, https://www.brahminsnet.com/forums/forum/friendship-gossip-social/20098- 9. According to Hinduism,do ghosts exist? - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/hinduism/comments/17l54wo/according_to_hinduismdo_ghosts_exist/ 10. religionmediacentre.org.uk, https://religionmediacentre.org.uk/news/jinn-the-unseen-and-paganism-what-does-islam-say-about-halloween/#:~:text=Muslims%20do%20not%20believe%20in,the%20dead%20returning%20to%20Earth. 11. do muslims believe in ghosts? : r/islam - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/sef2y0/do_muslims_believe_in_ghosts/ 12. How Does Islam View Ghosts? - IslamOnline, https://fiqh.islamonline.net/en/how-does-islam-view-ghosts/ 13. What Should Muslims Believe About Ghosts? - SeekersGuidance, https://seekersguidance.org/answers/islamic-belief/what-should-muslims-believe-about-ghosts/ 14. Should Muslims Believe in Ghosts, Spirits and Demons? - HalalZilla, https://www.halalzilla.com/muslims-ghosts-spirits-demons/4351 15. Do muslims believe in ghosts? - Quora, https://www.quora.com/Do-muslims-believe-in-ghosts 16. The Arab Muslims' Belief in Ghosts and Spirits : A Case Study ... - J-Stage, https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/ajames/7/0/7_KJ00004403568/_article/-char/en 17. Muslim Beliefs in the Supernatural and Related Practices - Pew Research Center, https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2012/08/09/the-worlds-muslims-unity-and-diversity-4-other-beliefs-and-practices/ 18. Islam and magic - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_and_magic 19. Spirit possession and exorcism in Islam - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirit_possession_and_exorcism_in_Islam 20. Intercourse Through the Jinn; Spirits, Demons, and Ghosts in Islam, https://www.answering-islam.org/Books/Macdonald/haskell_lecture5.htm 21. What Does the Bible Say About Ghosts? | LCBC Church, https://www.lcbcchurch.com/articles/what-does-the-bible-say-about-ghosts 22. What does the Bible say about ghosts / hauntings? | GotQuestions.org, https://www.gotquestions.org/ghosts-hauntings.html 23. Can Christians Believe in Ghosts? | Christianity.com, https://www.christianity.com/wiki/holidays/can-christians-believe-in-ghosts.html 24. What Are Ghosts? | Catholic Answers Magazine, https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/what-are-ghosts 25. Ghosts, haunted houses and bumps in the night: What the Bible really says about all things spooky - Premier Christianity Magazine, https://www.premierchristianity.com/features/ghosts-haunted-houses-and-bumps-in-the-night-what-the-bible-really-says-about-all-things-spooky/5510.article 26. What Does the Bible Say about Ghosts? | Christianity.com, https://www.christianity.com/wiki/holidays/what-does-the-bible-say-about-ghosts.html 27. What Does the Bible Say about Ghosts? - Theology - Christian Forums at Crosswalk, https://forums.crosswalk.com/t/what-does-the-bible-say-about-ghosts/3315 28. Spirits, Ghosts, and Angels | Answers in Genesis, https://answersingenesis.org/contradictions-in-the-bible/spirits-ghosts-and-angels/ 29. What does Christianity say about ghosts? - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Christianity/comments/17drhfh/what_does_christianity_say_about_ghosts/ 30. Ghosts Are Universal, But What You See is Influenced By What You Already Believe, https://bigthink.com/surprising-science/ghosts-are-universal-but-what-you-see-is-influenced-by-what-you-already-believe/ 31. Ghost: Significance and symbolism, https://www.wisdomlib.org/concept/ghost 32. Ghosts in Buddhism : r/Buddhism - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Buddhism/comments/1dnxry8/ghosts_in_buddhism/ 33. Hungry ghost - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungry_ghost 34. Ghosts, Nagas, Demons and Duality: Are Supernatural Beings Cogenerated, Illusory, Dream or Ultimately Real? - Buddha Weekly: Buddhist Practices, Mindfulness, Meditation, https://buddhaweekly.com/ghosts-nagas-demons-and-duality-are-supernatural-beings-cogenerated-illusory-dream-or-ultimately-real/ 35. Buddhist Ghosts. . . | The Daily Buddha, https://www.thedailybuddha.com/buddhist-ghosts/ 36. Spirits in Buddhism? - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Buddhism/comments/v4gaiw/spirits_in_buddhism/ 37. “The Realm of Hungry Ghosts”: The Buddhist Notion that explains our strive for Perfectionism. | elephant journal, https://www.elephantjournal.com/2022/01/the-realm-of-hungry-ghosts-the-buddhist-notion-that-explains-our-strive-for-perfectionism-rasha-al-jabi/ 38. Gurbani Defines Ghost – Bhoot Pret – Gurbani Blog ... - gurbani.org, https://www.gurbani.org/gurblog/ghost-pret-defined/ 39. Do Ghosts Exist? - SikhiWiki, free Sikh encyclopedia., https://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Do_Ghosts_Exist%3F 40. Ghosts and Evil Spirits | Sadh Sangat, https://www.sadhsangat.com/ghosts-and-evil-spirits/ 41. Do Sikhs Believe in the Devil or Demons? - Learn Religions, https://www.learnreligions.com/do-sikhs-believe-devil-or-demons-2993497 42. Ghosts – Sikh Dharma International, https://www.sikhdharma.org/ghosts/ 43. Real Ghosts | WaheguruNet, https://wahegurunet.com/real-ghosts/ 44. Primary Beliefs and Principles - SikhiWiki, free Sikh encyclopedia., https://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Primary_Beliefs_and_Principles 45. Sikhism and the Afterlife - Learn Religions, https://www.learnreligions.com/sikhs-believe-about-the-afterlife-2993490 46. Does gurbani talk about whether ghosts are real? : r/Sikh - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Sikh/comments/u33iti/does_gurbani_talk_about_whether_ghosts_are_real/ 47. What is the Jewish View on Ghosts? - OU Life - Orthodox Union, https://www.ou.org/life/inspiration/jewish-view-ghosts/ 48. What is Judaism's take on ghosts? - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/Judaism/comments/43mkdc/what_is_judaisms_take_on_ghosts/ 49. Judaism & ghosts - Roots Metals, https://www.rootsmetals.com/blogs/news/judaism-ghosts 50. Ghosts, Spirits, and Jewish wanderings in the Afterlife, https://www.myjewishlearning.com/2013/10/30/ghosts-spirits-and-jewish-wanderings-in-the-afterlife/ 51. Do (Jewish) Ghosts Exist? - Jewish Book Council, https://www.jewishbookcouncil.org/pb-daily/do-jewish-ghosts-exist 52. Demons, Dybbuks, Ghosts, & Golems | My Jewish Learning, https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/demons-dybbuks-ghosts-golems/ 53. Meet Judaism's Demons, Spirits, Witches & Ghosts - Hey Alma, https://www.heyalma.com/meet-judaisms-demons-spirits-witches-ghosts/ 54. Demons & Demonology - Jewish Virtual Library, https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/demons-and-demonology 55. What was the ancient Jewish understanding of ghosts? : r/AcademicBiblical - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/AcademicBiblical/comments/zqs8zg/what_was_the_ancient_jewish_understanding_of/ 56. Holy Spirit in Judaism - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Spirit_in_Judaism 57. Shining Brighter Together: Two Anthropologists Explore the Spirit World in New Book - Office of the Provost - University of Missouri, https://provost.missouri.edu/shining-brighter-together-two-anthropologists-explore-the-spirit-world-in-new-book/